Hubcap Heaven sells wheels and wheel covers.
Something like the old logo - but original and better-looking art instead.
I have attached the old logo here so you can see the idea. Same concept is fine - a wheel or hubcap with a halo, or whatever you imagine.
Colors should be black, white, and blue.
This is part of a re-branding effort and web site rebuild so go ahead and be creative! Your logo will drive the redesign.