The Facebook group is named The Athlete in You Never Goes Away and is for former athletes interested in pursuing entrepreneurship or those who are already involved entrepreneurs.
Both of my avatars miss the energy they had during sports and are both over-achievers who aren't satisfied with where they are at.
One avatar already believes in the statement The Athlete in You Never Goes Away because they feel it and are ready to unleash it again. The other is uncertain but wants that statement to be true. Neither of them have truly felt like themselves in years and are dying to get back to that state.
I'd like the design to reflect this and have a sense of energy and encouragement to it, without being overly aggressive. For colors I like black, charcoal, gold, silver, blue, white. No need to use all of those colors. I envision black/charcoal being the primary and gold and/or blue as the accents. I see the font as white in my head but it doesn't have to be. Silver is probably my least favorite of those colors.
Sports themed backdrop or sports balls are welcomed if done tastefully and it flows with the color palate. Definitely not necessary. I see this as being a background image that has a deep tint on/black or charcoal with opacity.
I also see there being like a fade to the design in some way. Maybe by using a chalk-esque theme. This in my mind is to capture the sense of something fading away, this will represent how they feel about a past version of themselves.
Please reach out with any questions or clarifications!